Friday, April 27, 2012

Contract Brewing VS Alternating Proprietorship

There are options, believe it or not, for brewers who don't have the $1,000,000+ to sink into a production brewery or brewpub and don't think a nanobrewery will be profitable at such a small scale.

Contract Brewing is a situation where you provide a recipe to a brewer and they produce the beer on their system and you then purchase the kegs and/or bottles. The owner of the kegs would most likely possess a wholesale license which would allow them to sell to bars and restaurants.

There are several examples where this relationship has been shown to be beneficial to both parties and the industry. For example, when Lagunita's Brewing was increasing their production some of their tanks were damaged during transport... putting them behind schedule. Their friends at Anchor Brewing managed to help them pick up the slack. Another example is with 21st Amendment in San Francisco who own a pilot system for smaller production but get much of their product is brewed and canned at Cold Spring Brewery in MN.


Despite these cases, contract brewing still has a negative connotation for many who remember the beer boom of the 90s. Any wanna-be business man with zero brewing knowledge could come up with a ridiculous beer idea to market and pay a struggling brewery to make it for them. With many of these "craft beers"  flooding the market it began to leave a sour taste in the mouths of legitimate brewers and beer enthusiast.

Things are changing, however, and in my opinion if it is done under full transparency and honesty by people who really understand beer it can be a great option for a new company.

Another option is an Alternating Proprietor relationship where you actually "own" the brewery under specific conditions and times. You are essentially renting a brewery and using their system to produce your beer. One advantage to this is the right to actually call your company a "brewery" (unlike with contract brewing where you can't use the term). In some states it is also easier for a brewery... which you would be licensed as... to open a tasting room than it would be for someone with a different license type.

This requires much more paper work and potential up-front cost but it tends to be more profitable to the brewer because they are not paying the mark-up you would find with a contract relationship. 

One famous example of a brewery utilizing this arrangement would be Mikkeller Brewing who travels around the world brewing on various systems.
One concern for both Contract brewers and Alternating Proprietor brewers is whether or not your host brewery has enough room in their facility or in their schedule to have you occupy one of their fermentation vessels. The solution to this, which has been used by some, is for the tenant brewer to purchase a fermentor and have it on site so they are guaranteed to always have room for their beer. When not in use it can be rented by the host brewery to increase their production.

If you are interested in introducing beer to market without investing a fortune, it may be worth your time to look into these options.

Good Luck!

Tragic Accident at Redhook Brewing

On April 24th Ben Harris, an employee at Red Hook Brewing's Portmouth, NH facility was fatally wounded when a keg he was working on exploded.

Details of the incident from Redhook:

There is an assessment underway to reveal exactly what happened Tuesday morning. Although the investigation is still in process, there are several facts that we can confirm:


• The accident was caused by an exploding plastic keg ;
• The keg was not owned or used by Redhook Brewery or any other CBA brewery;
• It is normal protocol for the brewery to receive kegs that aren’t ours from time to time;
• Ben was handling the keg at the time it exploded.

You can read the rest of the statement from Redhook Brewing HERE


I would like to send my condolences to his family.

The family asks that memorial contributions be made to: The Alysha Miller Harris Baby Fund c/o TD Bank, 20 International Drive, Portsmouth, NH, 03801, (603) 430-3812.